Waiting It Out or Raising the Heat
The options when meat stalls are to wait, wrap, or cook hotter. Here's what each one changes, according to cited sources, and what each costs.
There are three real choices when a stall hits: wait, wrap, or cook hotter. Each one works on the same cause, which is evaporation, and each costs you something different.
First, rule out a dying fire
A flat probe reading and a falling cooker temperature aren't the same problem. Check the cooker's own thermometer before changing anything. Fuel, vents and the weather can all pull the heat down, and no stall advice fixes that. Run the cooker outdoors, and follow its manual for vents, fuel and settings.
Option one: wait
Waiting changes nothing about the meat. The stall lasts until the surface moisture runs low, and the temperature then rises again. One test of a small brisket found the reading rose much more rapidly after the plateau1.
What you give up is time, and the amount isn't predictable. Low-temperature smoking already runs for several hours2. If a meal depends on the schedule, waiting is the choice that puts the most pressure on the clock.
Option two: wrap
Foil stops the water leaving, so the temperature climbs faster. The source ties that to the foil blocking evaporative cooling completely1. What you lose by wrapping is covered in the Texas crutch page.
Option three: cook hotter
The same source reports that if you cook meat in a hot oven, the stall disappears1. That was an indoor oven test. The source gives no result for turning up an outdoor smoker or grill. This site only covers outdoor cooking, so don't take it as a reason to move a smoker or grill inside.
Cooking hotter means you're no longer cooking low and slow, and tougher cuts rely on that long, gentle time. Stay within the temperature range your cooker's manual allows.
Options people ask about
- Spritzing. In the author's test with a pork tenderloin, the cooling after spraying was modest and recovered quickly1. So don't expect spraying to change a stall much.
- A water pan. Extra humidity, whether from a water pan or a wet mop, will slow down the cooking process1. Its stall is also described as prolonged in humid conditions1.
- Airflow. How fast evaporation runs depends on the temperature and humidity of the air3. In that write-up, extra airflow helped or hurt cooking time depending on the meat1.
What each choice changes
| Choice | What it acts on | What you trade |
|---|---|---|
| Wait | Nothing. Evaporation finishes by itself. | Time, and an uncertain end |
| Wrap | Blocks evaporation | A different flavor |
| Cook hotter | In an oven test, the stall disappeared | The low, slow style |
Whichever you pick
Don't chase the number. Keep checking the probe. For food safety, see food safety and the stall.
Reference list
- BBQ stall explained, Genuine Ideas (Greg Blonder)
- Barbecue, Wikipedia
- Evaporative cooler, Wikipedia