Why the Stall Happens: Evaporative Cooling
Moisture leaving the meat's surface carries heat away. Here's how that holds the temperature down, and which other explanations the tests ruled out.
The stall comes from water evaporating off the meat. Evaporating water takes heat with it, and for a few hours the heat leaving as vapor roughly matches the heat arriving from the cooker.
The same trick as sweat
Evaporative cooling is the conversion of liquid water into vapor using the thermal energy in the air, resulting in a lower air temperature1. Sweat is the everyday example. A damp bandana on a hot day works the same way.
Meat is mostly water. It holds that water in tiny pores and cells, and over a long cook it slowly works its way to the surface. Most of this page comes from a write-up by Greg Blonder. His conclusion was that the meat's own slowly released moisture cools it until that moisture runs out2. As the meat warms, evaporation speeds up until the cooling roughly balances the heat going in. Then the reading sits still.
What his tests did
He didn't only watch a brisket. He put a lump of beef fat and a soaked sponge into an unheated smoker, then set it to 225F. The fat kept rising in temperature, while the sponge stalled, just like the brisket2.
Why test a sponge? A sponge holds water in pores, as meat does, but it has no collagen and no protein to change. If it stalls anyway, the cause is physical rather than chemical. That's the reasoning he gave.
Ideas that didn't hold up
Fat rendering is a popular explanation. His answer was short: fat doesn't evaporate, it simply melts, and it holds too little heat of melting to delay cooking2.
Collagen melting is the other common one. He pointed out that collagen is a small share of the weight of typical cuts. There isn't enough of it to explain a long stall2. Two more tests pointed the same way. Meat wrapped in foil, which blocks evaporation, showed no stall. And meat cooked in a hot oven also lost its stall2.
Keep the limits in mind. These are one author's experiments, shared on his own website, and they weren't peer reviewed. The explanation is widely repeated, but this page can only vouch for what that source says.
The surface goes first
He also measured at two depths. The exterior begins stalling an hour before the interior2. So the pause moves inward from the surface, which fits the idea that it starts where the evaporating is happening.
What changes the length and the level
Several things shift how the plateau looks, according to the same source:
- Air movement. The faster air moves over a wet surface, the greater the cooling effect and the lower the stall temperature2.
- Humidity. The stall is rapid in dry environments and prolonged in humid ones2. The general rule for evaporation is the same: its rate depends on the temperature and humidity of the air1.
- Size. A large piece of meat contains a greater proportion of stored water, relative to its surface area, than a small piece of meat2. So it has more water to give up.
None of this means you can control a stall precisely. It does explain why two cooks on the same day can see different plateaus. How long they run is on the next page, how long a stall can last, and foil is covered after that.
Reference list
- Evaporative cooler, Wikipedia
- BBQ stall explained, Genuine Ideas (Greg Blonder)