How Long a Stall Can Last
Cited sources give few hard numbers for stall length. Here's what they do say, what changes it, and why no source can promise a time.
Nobody can give you a reliable time. The sources here show a stall of about two hours in one test and almost six hours in another, and that's about as far as the evidence goes.
The numbers that are written down
The Genuine Ideas write-up recorded a small brisket in an electric smoker set to 225F. Its internal temperature stalled at 153F for almost six hours, then rose much more rapidly1.
A different test used an eight-ounce piece of well-marbled rib roast. The solid piece of meat stalled for two hours around 150F, and the author said it kept enough moisture to go on stalling for another hour and a half1. Ground meat from the same roast, with its many channels for juices to drain, simply kept heating.
Those are single runs by one author. They show a range, not a rule.
The temperature isn't fixed either
The same source says meat often stalls around 160F when cooked low and slow. The shape of the curve depends in detail on the type and setup of each cooker1. So there isn't one magic number to watch for. A reading that sits still anywhere in that neighborhood, while the cooker holds its heat, is the pattern.
Low and slow is already a long haul2. A pause inside it can feel endless. Still, it ends.
What stretches it, and what shortens it
According to that write-up, several things matter:
- Humidity. The stall is rapid in dry environments, prolonged in humid1.
- Size. Big pieces store more water for each inch of surface than small ones, the author wrote, so they can supply more evaporating liquid and eventually cool to a somewhat lower stall point1.
- Air movement. Faster air over a wet surface cools more, and the author said more airflow can speed up or slow down cooking depending on the size, shape and type of meat1.
- Cooker design. He noted that electric smokers are pretty well sealed, while a pellet cooker uses a fan that pushes air through, so the two can behave differently1.
Why a fixed schedule fails
Because so many things shift it, a chart that says "the stall lasts X hours" is a guess. If you're planning a meal, the sensible approach is to leave a wide margin and watch the probe rather than the clock. That's an inference from the sources, not something any of them states outright.
One more point from the same write-up. In the brisket test, the reading rose much more rapidly once the stall ended1.
Telling a stall from a problem
A real stall has the cooker still holding its set temperature while the meat reading flattens. If the cooker's own air temperature is dropping, the flat line has another cause, such as fuel running low. That's a different fix. The pages on waiting it out or raising the heat and wrapping cover what you can change once you're sure it's a stall.
Reference list
- BBQ stall explained, Genuine Ideas (Greg Blonder)
- Barbecue, Wikipedia